Reply to Chen: Under specified assumptions, adequate random samples of skewed distributions obey Taylor's law.

نویسندگان

  • Joel E Cohen
  • Meng Xu
چکیده

Chen (1) simulated random samples of beta, lognormal, and Poisson distributions with varying parameters following the method that we (2) used for fixed parameters. Chen claimed that the relationship between the supporting rate of Taylor’s law (TL) and skewness is “complex and nonmonotonic,” as some random samples of some skewed distributions did not support TL. Chen did not consider two crucial issues: satisfying the assumptions of our theorem (2) and estimating the quantities in it adequately. For a beta distribution with parameters α and β, Chen fixed β = 0.5 and considered α as small as 0.01. It is known analytically (3) that values of α near zero give means and variances close to zero. A zero mean or a zero variance is contrary to assumptions of our theorem (2). When mean and variance are near zero, sample estimates of log(mean) and log(variance) and parameter estimates of TL become unstable. Thus, Chen’s observation that the supporting rate of TL fell toward zero (figure 1A in ref. 1) as α approached zero did not contradict our theorem. By contrast, when we fixed β = 0.5 and varied α ∈ [0.3,0.7] to avoid mean near zero and variance near zero in accordance with our assumptions, random samples of beta distributions yielded a high supporting rate of TL when α < β (positively skewed) and when α > β (negatively skewed), and a low supporting rate of TL when α ≈ β (skewness near zero) (Fig. 1A), confirming our theorem (2). With β = 0.5, the minimal mean and minimal variance using our α ∈ [0.3,0.7] were 0.375 and 0.1105, respectively, roughly 19 and 9 times the minimal mean and minimal variance using Chen’s α ∈ [0.01,0.5]. For a lognormal distribution, it is known analytically (3) that the skewness grows in proportion to exp(3σ/2) asymptotically for large σ. Chen fixed the lognormal parameter μ = 1 and varied σ ∈ [0.001,10]. The sample skewness computed by Chen severely underestimated the true population skewness as σ increased beyond about 2 (figure 1D in ref. 1 and Fig. 1H). Clark and Perry (4) and we (2) observed that lognormal sample variances underestimated lognormal population variances, with adverse effects on estimates of TL parameters. Because the underestimation of population variance (Fig. 1G) was more severe than the underestimation of population mean (Fig. 1F) when σ was large, it distorted the true log(mean)–log(variance) relationship and generated artificial nonlinearity (Fig. 1E), leading to a low supporting rate of TL (figure 1C in ref. 1). When we restricted σ to [0.001,1.2], a range where estimates of mean (Fig. 1F), variance (Fig. 1G), and skewness (Fig. 1 D and H) were relatively accurate, the results confirmed our theory (Fig. 1C). This range of σ was found in many scientific fields (table 2 in ref. 5, where s* = exp(σ) ∈ [1.001,3.32] if σ ∈ [0.001,1.2]). In conclusion, Chen’s examples using beta and lognormal distributions did not disprove our theorem (2). Rather, they violated its assumptions or estimated the quantities in it inadequately.

برای دانلود متن کامل این مقاله و بیش از 32 میلیون مقاله دیگر ابتدا ثبت نام کنید

ثبت نام

اگر عضو سایت هستید لطفا وارد حساب کاربری خود شوید

منابع مشابه

Estimation of Value at Risk (VaR) Based On Lévy-GARCH Models: Evidence from Tehran Stock Exchange

This paper aims to estimate the Value-at-Risk (VaR) using GARCH type models with improved return distribution. Value at Risk (VaR) is an essential benchmark for measuring the risk of financial markets quantitatively. The parametric method, historical simulation, and Monte Carlo simulation have been proposed in several financial mathematics and engineering studies to calculate VaR, that each of ...

متن کامل

Predictions of Taylor's power law, density dependence and pink noise from a neutrally modeled time series.

There has recently been increasing interest in neutral models of biodiversity and their ability to reproduce the patterns observed in nature, such as species abundance distributions. Here we investigate the ability of a neutral model to predict phenomena observed in single-population time series, a study complementary to most existing work that concentrates on snapshots in time of the whole com...

متن کامل

Consent in escrow: opting to opt in

In this paper, we reply to Taylor's (2015) peer commentary on consent-in-escrow. Specifically, we clarify the utility of this novel approach, the way in which it minimizes risks to participants, and how it differs from existing opt-out methods. We further explore its potential use in fields beyond disaster research.

متن کامل

Three-dimensional Magneto-thermo-elastic Analysis of Functionally Graded Truncated Conical Shells

This work deals with the three-dimensional magneto-thermo-elastic problem of a functionally graded truncated conical shell under non-uniform internal pressure and subjected to magnetic and thermal fields. The material properties are assumed to obey the power law form that depends on the thickness coordinate of the shell. The formulation of the problem begins with the derivation of fundamental r...

متن کامل

Statistics of Morphological Finite-State Transition Networks Obey the Power Law

Finite-state devices are widely used in natural language processing, yet little if anything is known about metrics and topology of finite-state transition graphs. Here we study numerically the structure of directed state transition graphs for several types of finite-state devices representing morphology of 16 languages. In all experiments we have found that distribution of incoming and outcomin...

متن کامل

ذخیره در منابع من


  با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید

برای دانلود متن کامل این مقاله و بیش از 32 میلیون مقاله دیگر ابتدا ثبت نام کنید

ثبت نام

اگر عضو سایت هستید لطفا وارد حساب کاربری خود شوید

عنوان ژورنال:
  • Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America

دوره 112 25  شماره 

صفحات  -

تاریخ انتشار 2015